Review · EDINBURGH
Edinburgh: Gin Tasting at Underground Venue
Edinburgh’s gin story gets a fitting setting below the Royal Mile. This one-hour tasting takes you into The Lost Close, an atmospheric underground venue behind St Giles Cathedral, where you sample four very different gins while learning how the drink changed from Jenever to Old Tom, Navy Strength, and London Dry. I like the setting, and I like that you mix each drink yourself with different tonics and garnishes. The main drawback is the short hour, so this is a lively introduction rather than a slow, technical tasting.
I also like the guides’ storytelling. Sarah is especially praised for her humor and historical detail, while Sara, Nicky, and Dan have also led sessions. This suits adults who want more than four quick pours, but it is not suitable for children, babies, or pregnant women, and it is held in English only.
Key points to know before booking

- The Lost Close setting: Enter an atmospheric underground space just off the Royal Mile, with one session even held in an old jail cell.
- Four contrasting gins: Taste a varied set of gins rather than four versions of the same style.
- Make your own serve: Choose from supplied tonics and garnishes to make each drink bold, dry, light, or refreshing.
- Gin through the centuries: Follow the spirit from Jenever to Old Tom, Navy Strength, and London Dry.
- Strong storytelling: Guides including Sarah, Sara, Nicky, and Dan bring history and humor to the hour.
- Simple central meeting point: Meet outside John’s Coffee House & Tavern on Parliament Square, behind St Giles Cathedral.
Why this tasting works better than a standard bar stop

Many gin tastings amount to a row of glasses and a quick list of ingredients. This one gives the drinks a setting and a story. You begin outside John’s Coffee House & Tavern, just off the Royal Mile, then head underground into The Lost Close. That change in level is part of the appeal. You are not simply sitting in another modern bar.
The venue gives the hour a slightly theatrical feel. One participant described sipping gin in an old jail cell, which captures the unusual character of the place without promising that every group uses that exact room. The close itself is tied to Edinburgh’s older built environment, and the guides bring the venue into the story rather than treating it as a neutral tasting room.
I like this approach because gin makes more sense when you can place it in time. The drink in your glass is not one fixed recipe. Its style, strength, botanicals, and mixer have changed over the centuries. The setting helps the history feel connected to Edinburgh rather than pasted onto a generic tasting.
More Gin Tastings in Edinburgh
- Edinburgh: Holyrood Distillery Whisky & Gin Tour
★ 4.6 · 982 reviews - Edinburgh: Vintage Bus Tour with Afternoon Tea or Gin
★ 4.4 · 699 reviews - Edinburgh: Holyrood Distillery Whisky and Gin Tour & Tasting
★ 5.0 · 533 reviews
Meeting behind St Giles Cathedral

The meeting point is outside John’s Coffee House & Tavern on Parliament Square. Look for it just off the Royal Mile, behind St Giles Cathedral. From there, the group heads underground to The Lost Close.
This is a useful location if you are already exploring central Edinburgh. You do not need separate transportation, and the activity fits neatly before dinner, after sightseeing, or at the start of an evening. The central position is also practical for a short booking, since the full experience lasts about one hour.
Take care with the timing of your day. The meeting point is easy to place on a map, but the tour does not include transport, and you need to arrive outside the tavern rather than simply wander into the underground venue on your own. Check the start time when booking.
Four gins, four different directions

The tasting includes four different gins. The point is variety, not volume. You get to compare styles and notice which flavors suit you.
Your guide explains the main flavor profiles and suggests a tonic and garnish for each gin. You then mix the drinks yourself. That small choice makes the tasting more useful than being handed four finished glasses. You can try a stronger pour with less mixer, or make a lighter, more refreshing drink if that suits your taste.
The supplied tonics and garnishes give you room to experiment, but the experience remains guided. You are not left to guess why one pairing works better than another. The guide helps you notice the relationship between the spirit and its mixer.
I would pay attention to your own reactions as you go. One gin may taste sharper, another sweeter or more aromatic, and a third may change considerably when you add tonic. The session is a good way to learn what you actually like before ordering a full drink at a bar.
The experience does not present gin as one simple flavor. It covers styles including Old Tom, Navy Strength, and London Dry, along with the earlier Jenever tradition. That range gives the tasting a clear shape. You are not just trying four products. You are seeing how gin’s identity changed over time.
From Jenever to London Dry

The history section follows gin from its earliest origins to the modern spirit. Jenever forms an early point in the story, followed by later styles such as Old Tom, Navy Strength, and London Dry.
You will hear about production as well as drinking. The guide explains how gin is made and how different traditions produced different results. The history also connects gin with Scotland, giving the tasting a local thread rather than treating the subject as a general alcohol lesson.
The exact balance between talk and tasting can vary with the guide and the group. Sarah is praised for keeping the historical material lively, with amusing stories and details about the venue. Other guides, including Sara, Nicky, and Dan, are also described as friendly, clear, and enthusiastic. A useful feature is the chance to ask questions. One guide stayed beyond the planned time to answer them, although you should not assume every session will run long.
This is history for a drink in your hand. You do not need prior knowledge, and the guides explain the terms as they go. If you already know your gin, you still get useful comparisons between styles and mixers.
More Gin Tastings in the UK
- Edinburgh: Gin Tour & Tasting – South Loch Distillery
★ 4.8 · 382 reviews - Edinburgh: Pickering’s Gin Jolly Tour (Distillery & Tasting)
★ 4.8 · 135 reviews - Edinburgh: Gin Distillery Tour and Tasting
★ 4.8 · 126 reviews - Bombay Sapphire Gin Distillery Tour and Cocktail
★ 4.5 · 725 reviews
Why tonic water gets its own place in the story

Tonic water is not treated as an afterthought. The session explains its original medicinal use and how it became gin’s familiar partner.
That detail matters because tonic changes the way gin tastes. A mixer can soften a strong spirit, add sweetness, sharpen citrus notes, or make the drink more refreshing. By trying different tonics with different gins, you see why the standard gin and tonic is only one possible combination.
The garnish matters for the same reason. It helps shape the final drink and gives you another way to test the guide’s suggestions against your own preferences. You are encouraged to create your own serve, but the tasting still gives you a framework.
For me, this is one of the most practical parts of the experience. You leave with a better idea of how to order gin in the future. You may discover that you prefer a particular style, a certain tonic, or less mixer than you normally use.
The guides make the difference

The strongest part of this experience is the guide. The setting is unusual, and the gin selection gives the hour substance, but the storytelling determines how well it all holds together.
Sarah receives repeated praise for being funny, warm, and well informed about both gin and the venue. She has been described as turning the tasting into a bit of theater, while still giving useful historical detail. Sara is also praised for her energy and storytelling. Nicky and Dan have been noted for their welcoming manner and clear presentation.
Do not expect a silent, formal tasting. The tone is social and conversational. The setting helps create an easy group atmosphere, and the format gives you natural points to compare impressions with the people around you. That works well for couples, friends, and solo visitors who enjoy a shared activity.
The group size can be small. One session had six people, which allowed plenty of interaction. Group size may vary, so you should not book on the assumption that every tasting will be that intimate. Still, the activity is built around conversation rather than a large lecture.
Is one hour enough?

One hour is enough for four tastings and a clear introduction to gin’s history. It is not enough for a long production tour, a visit to a distillery, or a detailed study of every botanical.
That limit can be a strength. You get a focused activity that fits into a busy Edinburgh day. It works especially well as an early evening plan, when you want an experience before dinner without committing to a long night out.
The pace will likely feel active. Each gin needs an explanation, a pour, a mixer choice, and time to taste. If you want to linger over each glass, take extensive notes, or ask a long list of technical questions, the hour may feel short.
I see this as an introduction with enough depth to feel worthwhile. It teaches you the main styles, gives you four comparisons, and adds a sense of place. It does not try to replace a full distillery visit.
Price and value at $36

At $36 per person, the value rests on more than the alcohol. You are paying for four gin tastings, tonics, garnishes, a guide, and access to The Lost Close. You also get a structured history lesson and a central Edinburgh activity that does not require transport.
The price makes sense if you value the setting and the explanation. Four drinks in a bar might cost a similar amount, but you would not necessarily get the background on gin, tonic, Scotland, or the venue. The self-mixing element also gives you a practical takeaway rather than four identical serves.
The value is less clear if you only want a large amount of gin or a relaxed drinking session. This is a guided tasting, not a night of free-form sampling. You are there to listen, compare, and learn as well as drink.
The high rating of 4.9 from 84 reviews reflects a consistent pattern: the guides, atmosphere, and varied gins are the main reasons people leave happy. Two four-star ratings still point to the same strengths, while suggesting that the experience will not be equally memorable for everyone. Your expectations should match the format: one hour, four samples, and a lively presentation.
Who should book this Edinburgh tasting?

I would recommend it to adults who enjoy local history, unusual venues, and guided food or drink experiences. It is particularly good for:
- Couples looking for a compact evening activity
- Friends who want to compare gin preferences
- First-time gin drinkers who want a clear introduction
- Experienced gin drinkers who enjoy learning about styles and mixers
- Visitors already near the Royal Mile
- Solo visitors who like small-group activities and conversation
It is not suitable for children under 18, babies under one year, or pregnant women. The tour is conducted in English, so you need to be comfortable following an English-speaking guide.
Because the experience involves alcohol, it is best placed as one part of your day rather than something you stack with several other tastings. You can make the drinks lighter or stronger, but the session still includes four alcoholic samples.
Booking details worth knowing
The experience costs $36 per person and lasts one hour. The guide speaks English, and transportation is not included.
You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund. A reserve-now, pay-later option is also available, which helps if your Edinburgh schedule is still changing. Check the available start times before you commit, then plan to meet outside John’s Coffee House & Tavern rather than at the cathedral itself.
Smoking is not allowed indoors. The venue is below street level, so follow the meeting instructions carefully and allow enough time to find Parliament Square.
Should you book The Lost Close gin tasting?
Book it if you want gin with a story, not just a drink. The combination of four contrasting gins, mix-your-own tonics, Edinburgh history, and an underground venue gives the hour a clear identity.
I would especially choose it for a first or second evening in Edinburgh, when you want something central and easy to fit around sightseeing. The strongest reason to go is the guide. Sarah, Sara, Nicky, and Dan have all been associated with warm, lively sessions, and the best moments come when the historical detail turns into a conversation.
Skip it if you want a long distillery visit, a technical production course, or a substantial evening of drinking. For everyone else, $36 is a fair price for a compact tasting that teaches you what you are drinking and helps you work out how you like it.
FAQ
Where does the Edinburgh gin tasting meet?
Meet outside John’s Coffee House & Tavern on Parliament Square, just off the Royal Mile and behind St Giles Cathedral. The group then heads underground to The Lost Close.
How long does the gin tasting last?
The activity lasts one hour.
How many gins are included?
You receive a tasting of four different gins.
Are tonics and garnishes included?
Yes. Tonics and garnishes are included, and you mix the drinks to suit your own preferences.
Is the tour conducted in English?
Yes. The live guide speaks English, and English is the listed language for the experience.
Is transportation included?
No. Transportation is not included, but the meeting point is in central Edinburgh near the Royal Mile.
Can I cancel or pay later?
You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund. A reserve-now, pay-later option is also available.
Freshly poured around Edinburgh
- Edinburgh: Port of Leith Distillery Tour & Tasting★ 4.8 · 200 reviews
- Stirling Castle, Highland Lochs & Whisky Tour from Edinburgh★ 4.7 · 204 reviews
- From Edinburgh: Islay and The Whisky Coast 4-Day Tour★ 4.9 · 55 reviews
- From Edinburgh: Scottish Highlands Tour with Whisky Tasting★ 4.8 · 628 reviews
- From Edinburgh: Full Day Scottish Highlands and Whisky Tour★ 4.5 · 136 reviews
- Edinburgh: Stirling, Whisky and St Andrews Tour in Spanish★ 4.5 · 83 reviews
- Edinburgh: Ultimate Whisky Experience★ 4.8 · 305 reviews
- Edinburgh: Small-Group History of Whisky Tour with Tasting★ 4.8 · 138 reviews
Gin Tastings, side by side.

Laid back, Yarra Valley Wine Tour: Wine, Cider, Gin, Beer + Choc
Read our review →
Melbourne: Yarra Valley Wine, Gin, Whisky and Chocolate Tour
Read our review →
Epic Yarra Valley Wine Tour + Lunch, Chocolate & Gin/Beer Option
Read our review →
Amazing Yarra Valley Wine Tour + Chocolate, Farm Fresh, Gin
Read our review →
Edinburgh: Holyrood Distillery Whisky & Gin Tour
Read our review →
Bombay Sapphire Gin Distillery Tour and Cocktail
Read our review →
Melbourne: Yarra Valley Wine, Cider, Gin, Beer, & Choc Tour
Read our review →
Edinburgh: Vintage Bus Tour with Afternoon Tea or Gin
Read our review →Lists this tasting sits in
