Review · EDINBURGH

Edinburgh: The Lost Close Underground Scotch Whisky Tasting

★ 4.7 · 474 reviews 1.5 hours From $53 Operated by 1A PSQ Ltd · Bookable on GetYourGuide
Book on GetYourGuide →

The most memorable part of this Edinburgh tasting is the setting. You leave the Royal Mile, descend below Parliament Square, and settle into The Lost Close, a recently uncovered underground space with a cosy, unusual feel. Then you taste four Scotch whiskies tied to Scotland’s main whisky-producing regions.

I like the way the guide connects each dram to place and history, rather than simply handing you a glass and naming the distillery. I also like the choice of tasting levels, from a friendly introduction to rare and high-end pours. The main consideration is that the standard tasting may feel brief if you already know your whisky, and the stronger intermediate pours can be a lot for a beginner.

Key points at a glance

Edinburgh: The Lost Close Underground Scotch Whisky Tasting - Key points at a glance

  • An underground Old Town setting: Enter The Lost Close from the meeting point behind St Giles Cathedral, just off the Royal Mile.
  • Four regional Scotch whiskies: Taste examples from each of Scotland’s major whisky-producing regions and compare their character.
  • A story-led tasting: Guides such as Eleanor, Rosie, Mark, Sarah, and Nikki mix whisky facts with tales of the people and odd characters behind the industry.
  • Three tasting levels: Start with the standard flight, choose four rarer and older whiskies at intermediate level, or select five top-shelf drams.
  • Small-group atmosphere: Small groups are available, and some sessions divide larger groups into two, leaving more room for questions.
  • A short, useful stop: The advertised time is 1.5 hours, though some sessions may run closer to 60 to 75 minutes.

Descending beneath Edinburgh’s Old Town

Edinburgh: The Lost Close Underground Scotch Whisky Tasting - Descending beneath Edinburgh’s Old Town

The meeting point is outside John’s Coffee House & Tavern, just off the Royal Mile and behind St Giles Cathedral on Parliament Square. This is a handy central location, but pay attention to the wording: you are not meeting at a separate distillery or visitor centre. You meet above the venue, then go underground with your guide.

That descent is part of the appeal. Edinburgh’s Old Town is full of lanes, closes, vaults, and rooms built into the slopes below the streets. The Lost Close gives your whisky tasting a physical sense of place. You are not simply sitting in a bright modern bar with bottles lined up behind the counter.

The room is described as cosy, private, and unusual. That suits the format well. Whisky is a drink that rewards conversation, and the underground space helps create a quieter setting for listening, asking questions, and comparing what you taste with the people around you.

The venue is not suitable for wheelchair users, so this is important to check before booking. The experience also involves alcohol in an enclosed indoor space, and smoking is not allowed indoors.

More Whisky Tastings in Edinburgh

Four whiskies from Scotland’s main regions

Edinburgh: The Lost Close Underground Scotch Whisky Tasting - Four whiskies from Scotland’s main regions

The standard option includes four whiskies from the major whisky-producing regions of Scotland. The point is not simply to taste four unrelated brands. Your guide uses the flight to show how climate, production choices, and local tradition can shape the character of Scotch.

You might begin with a lighter or more approachable style before moving toward whisky with more weight, spice, or smoke. The exact bottles can vary, so I would treat the tasting as a lesson in comparison rather than a guarantee of particular labels.

The Islay pour can be a sticking point for people who dislike peated whisky. Peat gives whisky a smoky, earthy quality, and it can dominate your first impression. The guide team has shown flexibility here, offering a non-peated Islay option so you can still experience the region without forcing down a flavour you dislike.

That is a useful detail for beginners. You do not need to arrive with a taste for smoke, nor do you need to pretend to enjoy every style. Tell your guide what you like. The tasting works best when the discussion responds to your palate instead of treating the four glasses as a fixed test.

You will likely hear the basic vocabulary of whisky tasting as you go. Your guide may draw attention to aroma, sweetness, spice, smoke, finish, and the way the whisky feels in your mouth. You may also hear about the legs left on the side of the glass after swirling, though the guide will help you separate entertaining tasting habits from genuinely useful clues.

Whisky history with a human touch

Edinburgh: The Lost Close Underground Scotch Whisky Tasting - Whisky history with a human touch

The history here is not presented as a dry list of dates. The guides tell stories about the strange characters, risky decisions, and changing fortunes that helped Scotch whisky become a major Scottish industry.

That story matters because it gives the tasting some shape. You learn why whisky developed in different parts of the country, how the industry grew, and why regional identity still matters when you compare one dram with the next.

The guides are the heart of the experience. Eleanor is praised for keeping the mood relaxed while helping both beginners and whisky fans learn something new. Rosie brings humour and a strong sense of the historical story. Mark is known for explaining regional differences and offering bottle suggestions. Nikki has handled questions and adapted premium tastings to personal preferences.

Other guides named in the sessions include Sarah, Hayley, Lydia, James, Dan, and Nickey. The individual style will vary, but the consistent strength is the human delivery. This is not a silent tasting where you are left to read labels. You get a host who explains, jokes, answers questions, and keeps the group moving.

I would book this mainly for the guide-led conversation, not just for the alcohol. You can buy whisky in shops across Edinburgh. What you cannot easily reproduce is the combination of a structured flight, regional context, and a host who can adjust the discussion to your level.

Choosing the right tasting level

Edinburgh: The Lost Close Underground Scotch Whisky Tasting - Choosing the right tasting level

The $53 standard price gives you four whiskies and an introduction to Scotch tasting. For a first whisky experience, that is the sensible starting point. You get enough variety to notice contrasts without committing to an expensive bottle or a long formal course.

The intermediate upgrade includes four rarer, older, or less common whiskies. These may be bottles you would not normally find in a whisky shop, or older versions of familiar names. This option makes more sense if you already know a few Scotch styles, if you are visiting specifically for whisky, or if you want to compare standard expressions with something less familiar.

The high-end choice includes five top-shelf drams. Think of it as the option for bottles you might admire in a shop but would not buy for yourself. It is also a good choice for a special occasion, such as a birthday or anniversary, especially if one person in your party is a serious whisky fan.

You do not have to choose the same level as everyone else. One couple booked the standard experience for one person and the higher-end tasting for the other, making the occasion work for two different budgets and interests. That flexibility is useful, though you should expect the group to share the same general presentation while the actual pours differ.

A word of caution: older and premium whisky is not automatically better for every palate. Intermediate pours can be strong for someone new to whisky. If you are unsure, start with the standard flight and ask the guide what might suit you. A more expensive dram will not help if the style is too smoky, intense, or alcoholic for your taste.

What the 90 minutes feels like

Edinburgh: The Lost Close Underground Scotch Whisky Tasting - What the 90 minutes feels like

The advertised duration is 1.5 hours. In practice, some sessions may take about 60 to 75 minutes, so I would think of this as a compact tasting rather than a long evening event.

You meet the guide, head down to the venue, and settle in before the tasting begins. The guide introduces the whisky basics and the story of Scotch, then takes you through the regional pours. Each glass gives you a fresh point of comparison, while the stories keep the session from feeling like a technical lecture.

The pace appears to be relaxed rather than rushed. Larger groups may be split into two smaller groups, which gives you more room to hear the guide and take part in the conversation. Small-group sessions are also available.

That format makes the tasting easy to place in an Edinburgh schedule. You can fit it between sightseeing and dinner, or use it as an early evening activity. Food is not included, so do not treat the tasting as a meal. Have a plan for dinner afterward, especially if you choose the intermediate or high-end option.

Transportation is also not included, but the location is central in the Old Town. You make your own way to Parliament Square, and the guide takes you from there.

Value at $53 per person

Edinburgh: The Lost Close Underground Scotch Whisky Tasting - Value at $53 per person

At $53, the standard tasting is not the cheapest way to drink whisky in Edinburgh. You could buy a dram at a pub for less. That comparison misses the point, though. Here you are paying for four samples, a guide, a history lesson, a structured regional comparison, and access to an underground venue.

I think the price is fair if you are curious about Scotch and want help making sense of the choices. Whisky menus can be confusing, especially when you are faced with regions, ages, cask types, and peated styles without much explanation. A guided tasting can save you from buying a bottle you will not enjoy.

The value improves if you use the session to learn your own preferences. Pay attention to the whisky you return to, not just the one with the grandest reputation. Ask what made you prefer it. Was it fruit, sweetness, spice, smoke, weight, or the finish? That answer can guide future purchases.

The premium options need a more personal calculation. They are best for someone who already enjoys whisky or for a gift occasion. If your main aim is to learn the basics, the standard tasting should be enough. If your aim is access to unusual bottles, the intermediate option may offer the best middle ground.

Some people have bought a bottle afterward, using the guide’s advice. That can add value, but there is no need to feel pressured. The setting is informal, and the experience is not built around a hard sell.

Who will enjoy The Lost Close most

Edinburgh: The Lost Close Underground Scotch Whisky Tasting - Who will enjoy The Lost Close most

This is a strong choice for a first Scotch tasting. You do not need prior whisky knowledge, and the guide can explain the essentials without making you feel out of place. It also suits a couple or group where one person knows whisky and the others are just curious.

The regional structure works well for people who want a quick overview of Scotland. You get a sense of how different whiskies can be, all within one sitting. The stories add context, so you leave with more than four flavour impressions.

It also suits a birthday or gift. One session included a birthday song for a visitor’s partner, and the high-end tasting can make the event feel more special. The underground setting helps too. You are paying for an experience with a sense of place, not just a row of samples.

I would be less likely to recommend it to someone who already has advanced knowledge and wants a long technical seminar. The standard flight is designed as an introduction, and the session is fairly short. In that case, choose the intermediate or high-end level, and make your expectations clear to the guide.

Children under 18 cannot take part, and the legal drinking age in Scotland is 18. The activity is not suitable for pregnant women, babies under one year old, or wheelchair users.

Practical tips before you book

Edinburgh: The Lost Close Underground Scotch Whisky Tasting - Practical tips before you book

Book an upgrade only if the style fits your interests. The intermediate option is appealing for rare bottles, but it may be intense for a new whisky drinker. The standard flight gives you a better foundation.

Arrive at the stated meeting point outside John’s Coffee House & Tavern, not simply at the general Royal Mile area. Parliament Square is busy, and the entrance to an underground venue may not be obvious if you are rushing.

Tell the guide what you already enjoy. If you do not like smoky whisky, say so before the Islay sample. The guide team has adapted that part of the tasting for people who wanted to understand the region without a heavy peat hit.

Leave time for food afterward. Four drams can be enough to make a difference, especially when you add the stronger premium pours. Food is not included, and the tasting is not intended to replace dinner.

Finally, use the guide as a resource. Ask which whisky suits your palate, what to look for in a shop, and which regional style to try next. The best result is not becoming an expert in one evening. It is learning what you like and knowing how to order your next dram with confidence.

Should you book The Lost Close tasting?

Edinburgh: The Lost Close Underground Scotch Whisky Tasting - Should you book The Lost Close tasting?

I would book this if you want a well-priced introduction to Scotch in a memorable Edinburgh setting. The strongest reasons are the underground room, the regional four-whisky format, and the guides’ easy storytelling. The experience has earned a 4.7 rating from 474 bookings, and the repeated praise centres on the hosts, the cosy atmosphere, and the useful range of whisky styles.

Choose the standard level for a first taste. Pick intermediate if you already enjoy Scotch and want harder-to-find pours. Go high-end for a special occasion or a committed whisky fan.

Skip it if you need wheelchair access, do not drink alcohol, or want a full meal with your tasting. For most curious visitors who have 60 to 90 minutes free in the Old Town, The Lost Close offers a focused way to learn the basics and sample Scotland through its whisky.

FAQ

Where does the whisky tasting meet?

Meet outside John’s Coffee House & Tavern, just off the Royal Mile behind St Giles Cathedral on Parliament Square. The group then goes underground from there.

How long does the experience last?

The advertised duration is 1.5 hours. Some sessions may take around 60 to 75 minutes.

How many whiskies are included in the standard tasting?

The standard option includes four Scotch whiskies from the major whisky-producing regions of Scotland.

Can I upgrade the whisky selection?

Yes. The intermediate option includes four rarer, older, or unusual whiskies. The high-end option includes five top-shelf drams.

Is the tasting suitable for beginners?

Yes. The experience is designed as an introduction to whisky tasting, with explanations of Scotch, regional styles, and the history of the industry.

Is the tour offered in English?

Yes. The live guide speaks English.

Can someone under 18 join the tasting?

No. The activity is not suitable for children under 18, and the legal drinking age in Scotland is 18.

Is The Lost Close accessible for wheelchair users?

No. The experience is not suitable for wheelchair users. It is also not suitable for pregnant women, babies under one year old, or indoor smoking.

Pour another

Whisky & Whiskey Tastings, side by side.

Every Whisky & Whiskey Tastings →
Edinburgh: The Scotch Whisky Experience Tour and Tasting
★★★★★★★★★★4.7· 5,213 reviews· from $33

Edinburgh: The Scotch Whisky Experience Tour and Tasting

Read our review →
Dublin: Jameson Whiskey Distillery Tour with Tastings
★★★★★★★★★★4.7· 4,859 reviews· from $35

Dublin: Jameson Whiskey Distillery Tour with Tastings

Read our review →
Melbourne: Yarra Valley Wine, Gin, Whisky and Chocolate Tour
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 3,667 reviews· from $93

Melbourne: Yarra Valley Wine, Gin, Whisky and Chocolate Tour

Read our review →
Dublin Irish Whiskey Museum and Gallery Guided Tour with Tasting
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 3,078 reviews· from $30

Dublin Irish Whiskey Museum and Gallery Guided Tour with Tasting

Read our review →
Edinburgh: Whisky Tasting with History and Storytelling
★★★★★★★★★★4.9· 2,451 reviews· from $24

Edinburgh: Whisky Tasting with History and Storytelling

Read our review →
Nashville to Jack Daniel’s Distillery Bus Tour + Whiskey Tastings
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 1,906 reviews· from $139

Nashville to Jack Daniel’s Distillery Bus Tour + Whiskey Tastings

Read our review →
Dublin Teeling Whiskey Distillery Guided Tour and Tasting 1 Hour
★★★★★★★★★★5.0· 1,765 reviews· from $24

Dublin Teeling Whiskey Distillery Guided Tour and Tasting 1 Hour

Read our review →
Edinburgh: The Johnnie Walker Whisky Experience
★★★★★★★★★★4.8· 1,670 reviews· from $40

Edinburgh: The Johnnie Walker Whisky Experience

Read our review →
Scroll to Top

Explore by the glass

Choose a grape, a grain or a still.